The Inside Story of How 382 Recruiters Pursued an Imaginary Engineer
In the fall of 2012, after reading about how Elaine Wherry set up a recruiter honeypot, we knew we had to invite her to First Round's CTO Summit to tell us all the inside story — so here goes.
Nearly three years after the launch of the factious Pete London, Pete got 530 emails from 382 recruiters, from 172 organizations. He was offered seven iPads, one Xbox, one MacBook Air, five $1,000 referral cash incentives followed by two $10,000 referral cash incentives, eight coffees, seven phone calls, and six lunch invites.
This is the story of Pete London and lessons learned in recruiting.
For weeks, the internet showed Pete London’s fake profile very little love, not that he was hard to find or that he had “weak SEO,” as tens of thousands of spammers were able to locate his email address. But when Wherry launched his LinkedIn profile, traffic popped. At the time, Meebo had found a mere 5% of its engineering talent that way, so it was surprising to see so much activity.
Find a way to really differentiate yourself and make sure that you stand out — not from the Amazons, the Facebooks and the Googles, but from all of the other startups around the Web.
"Does It Work?"
Inevitably, within a startup-context, you are going to have to hire external recruiters at some point when you’re looking to scale. The good news: They can work.
The graphic above alludes to the data — if you separate out the external recruiters for large established companies and small companies, it turns out that the external recruiters for small startups actually do a pretty good job. So until you can hire a recruiting team of your own, rest assured.
Be Very, Very Careful
The mentality that the more help you get the better (i.e. more external recruiters equals more success) is a dangerous one. Consider that when you invite external recruiters into your organization, you share with them intimate details about your company: org charts, financial data and more. This puts your company front of mind, specifically what expertise you have in-house. Accordingly, when they eventually go to another company to recruit, your startup might be their next target.
Wherry saw this firsthand at 2:20 on a May afternoon when Pete London received an email from a recruiter asking him to consider some potential job options. A mere 15 minutes later, Wherry, the engineering manager, got an email from the same person offering to help her find great talent. This external recruiter was pulling Wherry at both ends: literally saying, "Hey Pete, come out of Meebo," and then saying to the engineering manager, "Hey, let me help you find great talent."
Whenever you're working with external recruiters, ensure a "no poach" rule is clearly specified within the contract and be very specific about which external recruiters you work with.
Time for Hoodies
The graph above speaks for itself: Starting in 2010 through 2012, the amount of recruiting activity in San Francisco increased about tenfold.
Regardless of where you are right now, whether you're just starting to figure out where your location is or if you're an established company, your San Francisco strategy should be clearly drawn up or figured out.
Build Your Cavalry & Beat the Manager
When you're working with your in-house or your external recruiters, there is the notion because they are recruiters, they should be your cavalry. They should be the people who come in and save the day and allow you to go back and spend your time doing engineering and other parts of your role. But if you look at Wherry’s data managers, they were consistently within the top 40th percentile of all recruiting activity — better than the people hired to do just that.
Ultimately, if you want to have a recruiter do a better job, ensure they include two out of three pieces of personalization.
Start On the Right Foot
Make sure you start with a pro intro, which means putting personalization up front: Rather than sticking with a bland opening, try something specific.
Typical openings like “I was impressed with your profile,” “Sorry for the email,” and “Hi, my name is,” do not really help you stand out and are therefore ineffective (63% of Pete's emails looked fairly identical).
If you're feeling incredibly lazy, one way you could easily make your email better is if you look at this. After your recruiter has written that first draft, take out the first sentence. That's it. The resulting email is usually much, much better.
Follow Up, Don't Spam
Most of the emails directed to "Pete" came from an organization or came from a recruiter that he heard from previously. But a mere 12% acknowledged it was a follow-up.
Making sure your contact knows that it's your second time reaching out is critical as it helps to maintain a conversation history. As individuals, the longer the history we have with a given person, the stronger the relationship we perceive.
When you reach out to someone and say, "Hey, I wanted to see if you would be interested in this role," and then you reach out to that person again with, "Hey, I wanted to see if you would be interested in this new role. I’m really impressed with you," it implies ignored history and that the candidate is not really worth their time. The outreach immediately becomes less sincere and is interpreted as spam.
You, Your, Yours
Out of the hundreds of emails from 300+ recruiters, there were a mere five that stood out. As it turns out, however, they all shared the same thread: the use of the second person.
Do Not Do What I Did
Outside of finding good recruiters, employing the right sourcing techniques, beating a hiring crunch involves hiring more managers, and specifically managers who can help recruit. Their networks and expertise in reaching people in non-traditional ways will be beneficial, as opposed to bringing on individual contributors in a non-methodical fashion.
A Final Rule of Thumb
Solving the hiring crisis is a lot like any other engineering problem: You break down each piece of the process and you say, "Where are we losing people within our funnel?"
A good rule of thumb is to double check. Generally, your recruiter should be getting about a 12 to 20% response rate from cold outreach. That is just a good rule of thumb, so double check.
Read These Next
The Best Hires Are Right Under Your Nose - Use This System to Never Miss Them Again
Do you know where your first 10 employees are going to come from? How about the next 10? 99% of the time your best hires will come from your staff's combined network — you might already know that. But do you know how to go about mining that network so methodically that you get the most out of it? Probably not. As co-founder of talent discovery startup TalentBin, this is my bread and butter. This article is about how to proactively mine all the networks you have access to for early-stage hiring excellence. As a startup leader, it's critical to land remarkable first hires because that's where your next hires will come from. A lot of people talk about this, but they rarely walk through the nuts and bolts of how to do it. The key: Aggressive referral recruiting.
80% of Your Culture is Your Founder
When Molly Graham joined Facebook in 2008, the company still felt scrappy. With 400 employees serving 80 million users, people were so busy “moving fast and breaking things” that the culture still needed to be defined. Graham was hired to help make this happen — to not only tell the company’s story externally, but to build a shared vision and identity as it grew from 400 to thousands of employees. She started by asking two questions: 1) Who do we want to be when we grow up? 2) How do we talk to people outside about what it’s like to work at Facebook? Since then, these two questions have formed the foundation of Facebook’s culture discussions. Most notably, they resulted in the “hacker” identity that has distinguished the company as a technology powerhouse that is always experimenting to bring the world closer together. At First Round’s recent CEO Summit, Graham, who managed Culture and Employment Branding at the company for two years — and who now runs business operations for slick, modern word processor Quip — talked about what startup founders have to gain from defining culture early and often, and how to do this when there are dozens of competing priorities.
Here’s Why You’re Not Hiring the Best and the Brightest
What’s the most consistent piece of advice you get as a startup? Always hire the best people. Never compromise in your hiring standards, no matter how big your company gets. And it’s true. A great team can take an okay idea and transform it into an incredible, world-beating product. But something has always bugged me about this advice. There’s an elephant in the room in the form of an implied clause: Always hire the best people… who are willing to live in San Francisco. Substitute Mountain View, New York, Boston, Chicago, or any other city. The problem is the same. We pay lip service to the idea of hiring the best people in the world — but in reality, we’re only hiring the best people who happen to be close by. Call me crazy, but I think if we’re going to talk about hiring the best talent available, we should actually try to do that. This means letting go of the idea, at least in IT work, that people need to be physically present for any meaningful work to occur. There’s a better way.